Solveeit Logo

Question

Question: Three objects, A: (a solid sphere), B: (a thin circular disk) and C = (a circular ring), each have t...

Three objects, A: (a solid sphere), B: (a thin circular disk) and C = (a circular ring), each have the same mass M and radius R. They all spin with the same angular speed ω about their own symmetry axes. The amounts of work (W) required to bring them to rest, would satisfy the relation
1- wc>wb>wa{{w}_{c}}>{{w}_{b}}>{{w}_{a}}
2- wa>wb>wc{{w}_{a}}>{{w}_{b}}>{{w}_{c}}
3- wb>wa>wc{{w}_{b}}>{{w}_{a}}>{{w}_{c}}
4- wa>wc>wb{{w}_{a}}>{{w}_{c}}>{{w}_{b}}

Explanation

Solution

All the three bodies are rotating. They all have the same mass and same radius. They are spinning at the same angular speed. The axis of rotation is the symmetry axis. We need to find the amount of work needed to be done to bring them at rest. We can use kinetic energy to solve this problem.

Complete step by step answer:
For a body rotating, kinetic energy is given by the formula, K=Iω22K=\dfrac{I{{\omega }^{2}}}{2}, where I is the moment of inertia and ω\omega is the angular velocity. From work energy theorem work done is equal to change in kinetic energy. When the body stops, its final kinetic energy becomes zero. Here, the mass and radius for all the three bodies are the same M and r.
Moment of inertia for solid sphere is 2Mr25\dfrac{2M{{r}^{2}}}{5}, for circular disk it is Mr22\dfrac{M{{r}^{2}}}{2}and for circular ring it is Mr2M{{r}^{2}}.
So, kinetic energies of the three bodies comes out to be
For solid sphere(A)=2Mr2ω25\dfrac{2M{{r}^{2}}{{\omega }^{2}}}{5}
For circular disk(B)= Mr2ω22\dfrac{M{{r}^{2}}{{\omega }^{2}}}{2}
For circular ring(C)=Mr2ω22\dfrac{M{{r}^{2}}{{\omega }^{2}}}{2}

Thus, it is clear that wc>wb>wa{{w}_{c}}>{{w}_{b}}>{{w}_{a}}. So, the correct option is (1).

Note:
Here the three bodies were given and the moment of inertia is calculated about an axis passing through its centre of mass. So, the point to be kept in mind is the axis of rotation. Otherwise it is a simple and lucid problem. Work comes out in units of Joule, J.