Question
Logical Reasoning Question on Statements and Arguments
Not wearing a seatbelt in a moving vehicle is illegal and punishable. However, X argues that since not wearing a seatbelt can at most only harm the person who has chosen not to wear a seatbelt, and does not harm any other person, it should not be illegal or punishable.
Which of the following facts, if true, would weaken X’s argument?
A
People who don’t wear a seatbelt are likely to suffer severe injuries in the event of an accident, and consequently make use of public health resources such as government hospitals
B
In the event of an accident, people who are not wearing a seatbelt may also be thrown about and cause harm to other people or property
C
Both (a) and (b)
D
Neither (a) nor (b)
Answer
Both (a) and (b)
Explanation
Solution
The correct option is (C): Both (a) and (b)