Question
Question: Let $t$ be a real number satisfying $2t^3 - 9t^2 + \lambda = 0$ and $\lambda \in R$; then which of t...
Let t be a real number satisfying 2t3−9t2+λ=0 and λ∈R; then which of the following option(s) are correct?
A) If t=x+x1 in above equation then for exactly one value of λ the equation will have exactly 3 real and distinct solution of x
B) If t=x+x4 in above equation then for exactly one value of λ the equation will have exactly 3 real and distinct solution of x
C) If t=x+x1 in above equation then for exactly 6 integral values of λ the equation will have exactly 4 real and distinct solution of x
D) If t=x+x4 in above equation then maximum positive integral value of λ the equation will have exactly 2 real, distinct and positive solution of x, is 12

A
B
C
D
A, C
Solution
Let g(t)=2t3−9t2. The equation is g(t)=−λ. The derivative is g′(t)=6t2−18t=6t(t−3). The critical points are t=0 and t=3. The local maximum is g(0)=0, and the local minimum is g(3)=2(3)3−9(3)2=54−81=−27.
The number of distinct real roots of 2t3−9t2+λ=0 depends on −λ:
- One real root if −λ>0 or −λ<−27 (i.e., λ<0 or λ>27).
- Two distinct real roots if −λ=0 or −λ=−27 (i.e., λ=0 or λ=27).
- Three distinct real roots if −27<−λ<0 (i.e., 0<λ<27).
For a given real value of t, the equation t=x+xk (where k>0) can be written as x2−tx+k=0. The discriminant is Δ=t2−4k.
- If t2−4k>0, there are two distinct real solutions for x. This occurs when t>4k or t<−4k.
- If t2−4k=0, there is exactly one real solution for x. This occurs when t=±4k.
- If t2−4k<0, there are no real solutions for x. This occurs when −4k<t<4k.
Option A: t=x+x1. Here k=1, so 4k=2.
- t>2 or t<−2: 2 distinct real x solutions.
- t=2 or t=−2: 1 real x solution.
- −2<t<2: 0 real x solutions.
We want exactly 3 real and distinct solutions for x. This can happen if the set of distinct real roots of t results in a sum of x solutions equal to 3. For three distinct real roots of t, this sum is typically 2+1+0=3. This requires one root t1 giving 2 x-solutions, one root t2 giving 1 x-solution, and one root t3 giving 0 x-solutions. This means t1∈(−∞,−2)∪(2,∞), t2∈{−2,2}, and t3∈(−2,2).
Consider λ=20. The equation is 2t3−9t2+20=0. The roots are t=2, t=45±105.
- t1=2: N(t1)=1 (x=1).
- t2=45+105≈3.8: N(t2)=2 (since t2>2).
- t3=45−105≈−1.3: N(t3)=0 (since −2<t3<2). The total number of distinct x solutions is 1+2+0=3. Thus, λ=20 yields exactly 3 real and distinct solutions for x. It can be shown that this is the only value of λ for which this occurs. Option A is correct.
Option B: t=x+x4. Here k=4, so 4k=4.
- t>4 or t<−4: 2 distinct real x solutions.
- t=4 or t=−4: 1 real x solution.
- −4<t<4: 0 real x solutions.
We want exactly 3 real and distinct solutions for x. This requires a combination of N(t) values summing to 3, e.g., (2,1,0). This means one ti must be in (−∞,−4)∪(4,∞) (2 x sols), one tj must be ±4 (1 x sol), and one tk must be in (−4,4) (0 x sols). If t=4, λ=16. The roots are 4,41±33. t1=4⟹N(t1)=1. t2=41+33≈1.67⟹N(t2)=0. t3=41−33≈−1.17⟹N(t3)=0. Total x solutions = 1. If t=−4, λ=272. The only real root is t=−4⟹N(t)=1. Total x solutions = 1. It appears there is no value of λ for which exactly 3 distinct x solutions exist. Option B is incorrect.
Option C: t=x+x1. We need exactly 4 real and distinct solutions of x. This requires N(t1)+N(t2)+N(t3)=4. Possible combinations for distinct ti are (2,2,0). This means two roots ti,tj are in (−∞,−2)∪(2,∞), and one root tk is in (−2,2).
Consider the range 0<λ<27 for 3 distinct real t roots: t1<0<t2<3<t3.
- t3>3 always gives N(t3)=2.
- We need N(t1)+N(t2)=2.
-
Case C1: N(t1)=2 and N(t2)=0. t1<−2 and t2∈(−2,2) (and t2∈(0,3)). So t2∈(0,2). This requires roots t1<−2, t2∈(0,2), t3>3. We need to find λ such that this occurs. If λ=20, roots are 2,45±105. t1=45−105≈−1.3∈(−2,2), so N(t1)=0. t2=2, N(t2)=1. t3=45+105≈3.8>2, so N(t3)=2. Total x solutions = 0+1+2=3.
-
Case C2: N(t1)=0 and N(t2)=2. t1∈(−2,0) and t2∈(−∞,−2)∪(2,∞). Since t2∈(0,3), this is impossible.
-
Let's consider the case where the equation for t has 2 distinct real roots. This happens when λ=0 or λ=27. If λ=27, the roots are t=3 (double root) and t=−3/2.
- t1=3: N(3)=2 (since 3>2).
- t2=−3/2: N(−3/2)=0 (since −2<−3/2<2). Total x solutions = 2+0=2.
If λ=0, the roots are t=0 (double root) and t=9/2.
- t1=0: N(0)=0.
- t2=9/2: N(9/2)=2 (since 9/2>2). Total x solutions = 0+2=2.
Consider the range 0<λ<27. We have 3 distinct real roots t1<0<t2<3<t3. We need N(t1)+N(t2)+N(t3)=4. Since t2<3, N(t2) can only be 0. Since t3>3, N(t3) is always 2. So we need N(t1)+0+2=4, which means N(t1)=2. This requires t1<−2. So we need the roots to satisfy t1<−2, 0<t2<3, and t3>3. This combination of roots occurs when −27<−λ<0, i.e., 0<λ<27. We require t1<−2. The cubic 2t3−9t2+λ=0 has a root t1<−2. This means g(−2)=2(−2)3−9(−2)2=2(−8)−9(4)=−16−36=−52. So we need −λ<g(−2), which means −λ<−52, or λ>52. However, for 3 distinct real roots of t, we need 0<λ<27. This implies that the scenario N(t1)=2 is not possible when there are 3 distinct real roots for t.
Let's re-examine the condition for 4 distinct real solutions for x. This requires two roots of t to yield 2 x-solutions each, and one root to yield 0 x-solutions. So, we need two roots ti,tj such that ∣t∣>2, and one root tk such that ∣tk∣<2.
Consider the case where λ is such that there is only one real root for t. This happens when λ<0 or λ>27. If λ>27, there is one real root t1.
- If t1>2, N(t1)=2.
- If t1=2, N(t1)=1.
- If −2<t1<2, N(t1)=0.
- If t1=−2, N(t1)=1.
- If t1<−2, N(t1)=2. For λ>27, the single real root t1 must be less than 0. If λ=52, t=−2 is a root. N(−2)=1. If λ>52, then t1<−2, so N(t1)=2. For example, if λ=56, 2t3−9t2+56=0. t=−2 is not a root. g(−2)=−52. g(0)=0. Let's check λ=56. 2t3−9t2+56=0. t=−2 is not a root. g(t)=−56. Since −56<−27, there is one real root t1. g(−2)=−52. g(−3)=2(−27)−9(9)=−54−81=−135. So the root t1 is between -2 and -3. Since t1<−2, N(t1)=2. This gives 2 x solutions.
Consider the case where λ<0. There is one real root t1. If λ=−28, 2t3−9t2−28=0. g(t)=28. Since 28>0, there is one real root t1>3. If t1>2, N(t1)=2. For λ<0, the single real root t1 must be greater than 0. If λ=−28, t1>3. N(t1)=2.
We need exactly 4 real and distinct solutions of x. This requires two roots of t to give 2 x-solutions each. This means we need two roots ti,tj such that ∣ti∣>2 and ∣tj∣>2. And we need a third root tk such that ∣tk∣<2, which gives 0 x-solutions.
Let's consider the condition for 6 integral values of λ. We need N(t1)+N(t2)+N(t3)=4. This requires (2,2,0). This means two roots have ∣t∣>2 and one root has ∣t∣<2.
Consider the range 0<λ<27. Roots t1<0<t2<3<t3. N(t3)=2 since t3>3>2. We need N(t1)+N(t2)=2. Since t2∈(0,3), N(t2) can be 0 or 1 (if t2=2). If t2=2, then λ=20. Roots are 2,45±105. t1=45−105≈−1.3∈(−2,2), so N(t1)=0. t2=2, N(t2)=1. t3=45+105≈3.8>2, N(t3)=2. Total x solutions = 0+1+2=3.
We need N(t1)=2 and N(t2)=0. This requires t1<−2 and t2∈(−2,2) (and t2∈(0,3)). So t2∈(0,2). We need roots t1<−2, t2∈(0,2), t3>3. This implies λ must be such that g(t1)=−λ, g(t2)=−λ, g(t3)=−λ. We need t1<−2. This means g(t1)<g(−2)=−52. So −λ<−52, which means λ>52. But for 3 distinct real roots, we need 0<λ<27. This is a contradiction.
Let's reconsider the condition for 4 x-solutions. This implies two roots of t result in 2 x-solutions each, and one root results in 0 x-solutions. So, two roots ti,tj must satisfy ∣t∣>2, and one root tk must satisfy ∣tk∣<2.
Consider the case where λ is such that there are 3 distinct real roots for t. Let them be t1<0<t2<3<t3. We need N(t1)+N(t2)+N(t3)=4. N(t3)=2 (since t3>3>2). We need N(t1)+N(t2)=2. Since t2∈(0,3), N(t2) can be 0 (if t2∈(0,2)) or 1 (if t2=2). If N(t2)=0, we need N(t1)=2, so t1<−2. If N(t2)=1, we need N(t1)=1, so t1=−2.
Case 1: t1<−2, t2∈(0,2), t3>3. We need the cubic 2t3−9t2+λ=0 to have these roots. The condition t1<−2 implies −λ<g(−2)=−52, so λ>52. This contradicts the condition 0<λ<27 for 3 distinct real roots.
Case 2: t1=−2, t2∈(0,2), t3>3. If t1=−2, then λ=−g(−2)=52. For λ=52, the equation is 2t3−9t2+52=0. The roots are t=−2 and the roots of 2t2−13t+26=0, which has no real roots. So, for λ=52, there is only one real root t=−2. N(−2)=1. Total x solutions = 1.
Let's consider the range of λ for which we have 3 distinct real roots (0<λ<27). Let the roots be t1<0<t2<3<t3. We want N(t1)+N(t2)+N(t3)=4. We know N(t3)=2. We need N(t1)+N(t2)=2. Since t2∈(0,3), N(t2) can be 0 (if t2∈(0,2)) or 1 (if t2=2). If N(t2)=0, we need N(t1)=2, so t1<−2. If N(t2)=1, we need N(t1)=1, so t1=−2.
We need to find λ such that 0<λ<27 and either: (a) t1<−2, t2∈(0,2), t3>3. (b) t1=−2, t2∈(0,2), t3>3.
Condition (b) requires t1=−2, which means λ=52. This is outside the range 0<λ<27.
Consider condition (a). We need the roots to satisfy t1<−2, t2∈(0,2), t3>3. The condition t1<−2 means −λ<g(−2)=−52, so λ>52. This contradicts 0<λ<27.
There seems to be an issue with the analysis of Option C. Let's reconsider the conditions. We need 4 distinct real solutions of x. This requires the sum of N(ti) to be 4. Possible combinations for 3 distinct t roots: (2,2,0). This means two roots ti,tj must have ∣t∣>2, and one root tk must have ∣tk∣<2.
Let's analyze the boundaries for λ in the range (0,27). If λ→0+, roots are close to 0,0,9/2. t1≈0,t2≈0,t3≈9/2. N(t1)=0,N(t2)=0,N(t3)=2. Total=2. If λ→27−, roots are close to 3,3,−3/2. t1≈−3/2,t2≈3,t3≈3. N(t1)=0,N(t2)=2,N(t3)=2. Total=4. This happens as λ→27−. Let's check λ=26. 2t3−9t2+26=0. Roots are approximately t1≈−1.2, t2≈2.8, t3≈2.9. N(t1)=0 (since ∣t1∣<2). N(t2)=2 (since t2>2). N(t3)=2 (since t3>2). Total x solutions = 0+2+2=4. So, for λ=26, there are 4 real and distinct solutions of x.
We need exactly 6 integral values of λ. This means that for λ∈{21,22,23,24,25,26}, we get 4 solutions. Let's check the roots for λ=21. 2t3−9t2+21=0. Roots are approximately t1≈−1.1, t2≈2.5, t3≈2.6. N(t1)=0, N(t2)=2, N(t3)=2. Total = 4.
We need to find the range of λ for which t1<−2, t2∈(0,2), t3>3. This led to contradiction. We need to find the range of λ for which t1∈(−2,0), t2∈(2,3), t3>3. This gives N(t1)=0,N(t2)=2,N(t3)=2. Total = 4. This occurs when 0<λ<27. We need t2∈(2,3). The condition t2>2 means −λ>g(2)=2(8)−9(4)=16−36=−20. So λ<20. The condition t2<3 is always true for the middle root in the range 0<λ<27. We need t1∈(−2,0). The condition t1>−2 means −λ>g(−2)=−52, so λ<52. This is always true for 0<λ<27. The condition t1<0 means −λ<g(0)=0, so λ>0. This is true for 0<λ<27.
So, for 4 solutions, we need t1∈(−2,0), t2∈(2,3), t3>3. This requires 0<λ<20. The integral values of λ are 1,2,...,19. This is 19 values.
Let's check the boundary λ=27. Roots are 3,3,−3/2. N(3)=2, N(−3/2)=0. Total x solutions = 2.
Let's check the boundary λ=0. Roots are 0,0,9/2. N(0)=0, N(9/2)=2. Total x solutions = 2.
The number of x solutions changes when λ crosses values that make the t roots equal to ±2. We need to find λ such that the roots of 2t3−9t2+λ=0 are such that two of them are greater than 2, and one is less than 2. Let f(λ) be the number of x solutions. We found f(26)=4. The range 0<λ<27 gives 3 distinct real roots. The number of x solutions changes when one of the roots ti becomes equal to 2 or -2. t=2⟹2(8)−9(4)+λ=0⟹16−36+λ=0⟹λ=20. t=−2⟹2(−8)−9(4)+λ=0⟹−16−36+λ=0⟹λ=52.
If λ=20: roots are 2,45±105. t1=2⟹N(t1)=1. t2=45+105≈3.8>2⟹N(t2)=2. t3=45−105≈−1.3∈(−2,2)⟹N(t3)=0. Total x solutions = 1+2+0=3.
Consider the interval (0,27). When λ is close to 27, say λ=26.9, the roots are close to 3,3,−1.45. t1≈−1.45∈(−2,2)⟹N(t1)=0. t2≈3>2⟹N(t2)=2. t3≈3>2⟹N(t3)=2. Total x solutions = 0+2+2=4.
When λ is close to 0, say λ=0.1, the roots are close to 0,0,4.5. t1≈0∈(−2,2)⟹N(t1)=0. t2≈0∈(−2,2)⟹N(t2)=0. t3≈4.5>2⟹N(t3)=2. Total x solutions = 0+0+2=2.
The number of x solutions is 4 when t1∈(−2,0), t2∈(2,3), t3>3. This requires 0<λ<20. The integral values are 1,2,...,19. (19 values)
The number of x solutions is 4 when t1<−2, t2∈(0,2), t3>3. This requires λ>52. Not possible for 3 distinct t roots.
The number of x solutions is 4 when t1∈(−2,0), t2∈(0,2), t3>4. This requires t1∈(−2,0), t2∈(0,2), t3>4. The condition t3>4 means −λ<g(4)=2(64)−9(16)=128−144=−16. So λ>16. Combined with 0<λ<20, this gives λ∈(16,20). Integral values: 17,18,19. (3 values)
The number of x solutions is 4 when t1<−2, t2∈(0,2), t3∈(2,3). This requires t1<−2⟹λ>52. Not possible.
Let's analyze the number of solutions for different λ:
- λ<0: 1 real root t1>0. If t1>2, 2 x-sols. If t1=2, 1 x-sol. If t1∈(0,2), 0 x-sols.
- λ=0: Roots 0,0,9/2. N(0)=0,N(9/2)=2. Total 2.
- 0<λ<20: 3 distinct roots t1<0<t2<2<t3. N(t1)=0,N(t2)=0,N(t3)=2. Total 2.
- λ=20: Roots 2,45±105. N(2)=1,N(45+105)=2,N(45−105)=0. Total 3.
- 20<λ<27: 3 distinct roots t1<0<2<t2<3<t3. N(t1)=0,N(t2)=2,N(t3)=2. Total 4. Integral values: 21,22,23,24,25,26. (6 values)
- λ=27: Roots 3,3,−3/2. N(3)=2,N(−3/2)=0. Total 2.
- 27<λ<52: 1 real root t1<0. Since g(−2)=−52, and −λ is between −52 and −27, the root t1 is between -2 and 0. N(t1)=0. Total 0.
- λ=52: Root t=−2. N(−2)=1. Total 1.
- λ>52: 1 real root t1<−2. N(t1)=2. Total 2.
So, the number of x solutions is 4 for λ∈(20,27). The integral values are 21,22,23,24,25,26. There are 6 such values. Option C is correct.
Option D: t=x+x4. We need exactly 2 real, distinct and positive solutions of x. This requires t>4. We need the cubic equation 2t3−9t2+λ=0 to have at least one root t>4. Consider λ=12. 2t3−9t2+12=0. g(t)=−12. Since −27<−12<0, there are 3 distinct real roots. g(4)=−16. Since −12>−16, the largest root t3 is greater than 4. t1<0<t2<3<t3. t3>4⟹N(t3)=2. t2∈(0,3)⟹N(t2)=0 (since t2<4). t1<0⟹N(t1)=0 (since t1>−4). Total x solutions = 2. These solutions come from t3>4. The equation x2−t3x+4=0 has two distinct positive real roots since t3>4. So for λ=12, we have 2 real, distinct and positive solutions of x.
We need the maximum positive integral value of λ. We need at least one root t>4. This implies −λ<g(4)=−16, so λ>16. However, if λ>27, there is only one real root t1. If λ>27, then t1<0. If 27<λ<52, the root t1 is in (−2,0), so N(t1)=0. If λ=52, t1=−2, N(t1)=1. If λ>52, t1<−2, N(t1)=2.
Let's consider the condition for 2 real, distinct and positive solutions of x. This requires t>4. We need at least one root of 2t3−9t2+λ=0 to be greater than 4. Let h(t)=2t3−9t2. We need h(t)=−λ for some t>4. h(4)=2(4)3−9(4)2=128−144=−16. Since h(t) is decreasing for t>3, for t>4, h(t)<−16. So we need −λ<−16, which means λ>16. Also, for t>4, we need the root to be real. If λ>27, there is only one real root t1. This root must be <0. So no root t>4. If 0<λ<27, there are 3 real roots. t1<0<t2<3<t3. We need t3>4. This means −λ<h(4)=−16, so λ>16. So, for 16<λ<27, we have t3>4, which gives 2 real, distinct and positive solutions of x. The integral values of λ are 17,18,19,20,21,22,23,24,25,26. The maximum positive integral value is 26. Option D states the maximum is 12, which is incorrect.
Final check: Option A: Correct. λ=20 yields 3 x-solutions. Option B: Incorrect. No value of λ yields 3 x-solutions. Option C: Correct. For λ∈{21,22,23,24,25,26}, there are 4 x-solutions. Option D: Incorrect. The maximum integral λ is 26.
The correct options are A and C.
